Sterling Terrell

smart ideas from books (mostly)

  • Home
  • About
    • My CV
    • Books
    • Series
  • Newsletter
  • Advertising
  • Tools
You are here: Home / Potpourri / Naturalism Undoes Itself?

Naturalism Undoes Itself?

Naturalism Undoes Itself?

Naturalism undoes itself in the sense here that asks: Why should we trust human reason anyway?

And why should that reason be the ultimate arbitor or reality?

The long and short if it is that morals do not follow from naturalism.

The argument is structurally identical to the one he would make a couple of years later in his book Miracles, in a chapter called “The Cardinal Difficulty of Naturalism.” There he argues that if human reason is a product of the blind, undirected forces of natural selection, and unrelated in any necessary or intrinsic way to the way things actually are, then we cannot trust the claims made by the use of human reason, including the claim that human reason is a product of the blind undirected forces of natural selection. Naturalism, then, says Lewis, undoes itself.

-Alan Jacobs, The Year Of Our Lord 1943 (Amazon)

This reminds me of a lecture I heard in gradschool about the nature of reality.

It was, of course, obsurd – but the point of the talk was that life would not look much different if we were simply brains in an electrical vat living a simulation.

In a world of 100% naturalism, why trust human perception?

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: PotpourriTagged With: #Philosophy, #Reason

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Privacy Policy

Connect

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Free Weekly Newsletter:

Search

Top Posts

  • The Tricky Lily Pad Riddle (You Probably Can't Solve)
    The Tricky Lily Pad Riddle (You Probably Can't Solve)
  • Hyatt Hill Country Sunday House
    Hyatt Hill Country Sunday House
  • Can You Solve The Bat And Ball Riddle?
    Can You Solve The Bat And Ball Riddle?
  • The Week In Review - 298
    The Week In Review - 298
  • Another Great Riddle For You To Try
    Another Great Riddle For You To Try
  • 31 Persuasion Tips That I Learned From Scott Adams
    31 Persuasion Tips That I Learned From Scott Adams
  • The Tragedy Of Gina "Bronco" Bouza (1932-1957)
    The Tragedy Of Gina "Bronco" Bouza (1932-1957)
  • The Week In Review – 295
    The Week In Review – 295
  • The Week In Review – 297
    The Week In Review – 297
  • Not Offering Punchlines
    Not Offering Punchlines

Supporting = Loving

Recent Posts

  • Random Thoughts – 339
  • The 1999 Caedmon’s Call Guild Concert
  • Finally Making It
  • Thankful You Are Here To Chat
  • 2022 Kentucky Derby
  • Random Thoughts – 338
  • Cafe Energy
  • Instabooks 362
  • Overwhelming and Stressful
  • Oblique Humor Is Better Than Anonymity
  • Random Thoughts – 337
  • With You Watching Tinker Bell
  • This Celebrity Grew Up With John McEuen
  • The Magic Of Comedic Confidence
  • Random Thoughts – 336
  • Not Offering Punchlines
  • A Needle In A Haystack, Not A Haystack
  • Living Closer To All Of
  • Instabooks 361
  • Random Thoughts – 335
  • My Mad Money Stash
  • Where I Sit 22
  • Of Farming But It’s Mostly
  • Unique Comedy
  • Bathrooms I Despise

Copyright © 2022 · Generate Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in