Sterling Terrell

smart ideas from books (mostly)

  • Home
  • About
    • My CV
    • Books
    • Series
  • Newsletter
  • Advertising
  • Tools
You are here: Home / Potpourri / If You Throw Meaning And Ethics Out

If You Throw Meaning And Ethics Out

If You Throw Meaning And Ethics Out

I think this is saying that if you throw meaning and ethics out the window, everything becomes a practical statement.

But even a practical statement – in a world of only physics – is still arbitrary and meaningless.

The argument goes that “right or wrong” can have little basis in a world where only stardust exists.

You need a moral lawgiver for more than that.

The retort to this is often: “No, humans do not follow morals and ethics because of some creator giving us moral laws. We follow them because it allows us to cooperate together and survive.”

Lewis is pointing out that this objection is arbitrary and meaningless too.

Not all want to cooperate. And why are those that want to cooperate and survive any more right or wrong than those that don’t? Whay does any of it mean anything? And who are you to say either way? Why is thought A more or less valid than thought B? By what standard?

See it?

For if all values are socially constructed and in relation to Nature arbitrary, then even the claim that some act is necessary for the perpetuation of the human race is also arbitrary. For why should the human race survive?

-Alan Jacobs, The Year Of Our Lord 1943 (Amazon)

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: PotpourriTagged With: #Ethics, #Morals

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Privacy Policy

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Notifications of all new posts by email.

Connect

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Search

Top Posts

  • The Tricky Lily Pad Riddle (You Probably Can't Solve)
    The Tricky Lily Pad Riddle (You Probably Can't Solve)
  • 31 Persuasion Tips That I Learned From Scott Adams
    31 Persuasion Tips That I Learned From Scott Adams
  • Where I Sit 24
    Where I Sit 24
  • Where I Sit 25
    Where I Sit 25
  • Economics 101: Rosy Scenario Policy
    Economics 101: Rosy Scenario Policy
  • Instabooks 345
    Instabooks 345
  • The Tragedy Of Gina "Bronco" Bouza (1932-1957)
    The Tragedy Of Gina "Bronco" Bouza (1932-1957)
  • Can You Solve The Bat And Ball Riddle?
    Can You Solve The Bat And Ball Riddle?
  • The Massive Power Of Visual Persuasion
    The Massive Power Of Visual Persuasion
  • My Notes On, Kitchen Confidential, By: Anthony Bourdain
    My Notes On, Kitchen Confidential, By: Anthony Bourdain

Supporting = Loving

Buy Me a Coffee

Recent Posts

  • Where I Sit 25
  • Where Did I Set My iPhone
  • Where I Sit 24
  • Cold And Limp And All Of The
  • Random Thoughts – 375
  • King Of Love, By: I Am They
  • The Point Of Learning
  • Instabooks 371
  • A Dopamine Hit Just One
  • Random Thoughts – 374
  • A Leaders Necessary Exposure To Risk
  • The Compulsion To Read
  • Instabooks 370
  • With Tea Looking Out Of That
  • Random Thoughts – 373
  • Stayed Up All Night
  • Missed Internet Mania
  • Tenderloin, San Francisco
  • And That All This Is A Pause
  • Random Thoughts – 372
  • 100 Things That Made My Year – 2022
  • On Selling Popcorn
  • Instabooks 369
  • Solemn Week With My Parents
  • Random Thoughts – 371

Copyright © 2023 · Generate Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in